The excellent Noel Rappin led a great experiment on Mastodan yesterday. He asked for the “most elegant way” to do a trivial array manipulation in Ruby:
What’s your most elegant Ruby code that does this:
- takes an array of strings and a target string
- if the target string is not in the array, return the array
- if the target string is in the array, return the array with the target string moved from its position to the end of the array.
I love this question because it’s very simple, and yet leaves room for interpretation. What should
the code do if the target string is found more than once? What if the target in the dreaded
And what does “elegant” mean in the first place? Thanks of this relative vagueness, respondants
can express their personal taste and creativity, instead of focusing on algorithmic efficiency
(or start playing code golf).
Noel has gathered the results and they show an interesting diversity of styles. Some are very naive, but also easy to understand, even without any knowledge of Ruby (I believe). Others are much more cryptic.
Overall, if I was looking for a production-safe solution, I’d go with option 4:
It is short and legible, doesn’t mutate the array (a nice courtesy), and is a bit more sophisticated than non-idiomatic
techniques that would rely on
However, I have a certain fondness for more showy solutions, like option 8:
#tap being (in my opinion) misused, but here, combined with the
&& operator, it is very clever. I love
this, even if it’s basically hiding a conditional (because shortening it with a ternary operator is not enough!)
Do note that complicated is not necessarily clever. I find the option 6, for example, hard to read and yet pretty naive in its approach – the simplicity of the algorithm is just hidden behind a ternary operator and nested method calls:
Overall, my favorite solution is the one submitted by Henrik Nyh:
It is everything I love in Ruby: a bit weird and very smart at the same time (because it repurposes a little-used method,
#partition), concise, and yet legible. It makes you scratch your head, but only for a few seconds, and then you admire
its elegance. Awesome!